Author: ModernMedia

NHI Offers an Opportunity to Boost Primary Healthcare – We Must Seize it

By Russell Rensburg

To see National Health Insurance primarily as the setting up of a state-run medical aid scheme risks underplaying its massive potential to restructure how public healthcare services are organised and funded, and with that, its potential to boost the delivery of primary healthcare services in South Africa, argues Russell Rensburg.

It has been 30 years since South Africa emerged from centuries long racial suppression and state-sponsored apartheid and took her place among the community of sovereign, democratic nations. In 1996, we adopted the final Constitution, in which we committed to addressing the injustices of the past and building a society based on social justice and human dignity. That promise is carried through in the Bill of Rights, which under Section 27 includes the right to healthcare, food, and social assistance. The right to access healthcare services, like many socio-economic rights, is subject to the state taking reasonable legislative and other measures within available resources to progressively realise the right.

Pursuant to this, the National Health Act, which provides the framework for a structured uniform health system within the country, was adopted in 2003. The Act assigns the minister of health the obligation to ensure the provision of essential health services, which must include primary healthcare services. But, to date, no health minister has published regulations that define the exact scope of essential health services, nor has a framework been offered for the development of a defined package of care to be provided within the resources available.

The result is that, despite significant investments in public funded healthcare, the system and the services it provides has largely been shaped by existing infrastructure inequity. Put differently, health investments have typically gone where the infrastructure exists, rather than being guided by providing a defined package of primary healthcare services in all the places where it is most needed.

In the near term, the health system faces several immediate challenges. Per capita spending is declining. Spending is biased towards hospitals, with 42% of the national health budget spent on central and provincial hospitals. Another problem is that health service planning and budgets do not sufficiently account for our changing demographic profile –  life expectancy has increased and we have a growing population of young people.

The National Health Insurance (NHI) Act is an attempt to address this through the establishment of the national health insurance fund, which initially will be the only purchaser of public sector healthcare services. Broadly, the NHI aims to pool funds to provide access to good quality, affordable healthcare services for all South Africans and certain foreign nationals, based on their health needs and irrespective of their socio-economic status.

This shift marks a substantial change from the existing setup, where 85% of the national health budget is allocated at the provincial level. In South Africa, the share provinces get of the national budget is largely determined by the equitable share formula. The health component of the formula includes a number of variables to account for healthcare need, including premature mortality (as a proxy for unmet need ), multi index deprivation (to account for social determinants of health such as poverty ), income, housing, and measures of sparsity (to account for rurality). But the biggest driver of funding is historical utilisation, which shapes resource allocation at the provincial level. The result is that the funding is overly focused on providing care under the existing systems, rather than progressively expanding access to healthcare, and boosting access to primary care in particular.

In short, NHI represents a major shift away from this paradigm by which provinces receive healthcare funds via the equitable share and based on historic spending.

How it will work

Under NHI, the public sector will budget according to level of care, initially prioritising the district health system through the establishment of district health management offices. These offices will support contracting units for primary care, which will comprise a district hospital, community health centres , primary healthcare clinics, and ward based outreach teams as well as provisions for integrated practice comprising GPs, pharmacists, dentists, and rehab professionals (occupational health, physiotherapy, and speech therapy). The district health management offices will be responsible for the achievement of health outcomes in districts.

In theory, this will allow for healthcare priorities to be shaped at the district level and for services to be more responsive to the healthcare needs of communities. For example, a district like OR Tambo could prioritise more resources towards addressing maternal mortality by expanding ante-natal services or developing responses to address the health access gaps for older people in rural areas. In urban districts, like the City of Johannesburg, it could prioritise expanding access to reproductive health services by contracting in private health providers who are better placed to respond to the needs of working women. Ultimately, such a shift to a more responsive and more localised health system could also help increase uptake of TB and HIV prevention and treatment services across the board.

How to get the ball rolling

Reorientating our health system towards primary healthcare will be a difficult and time-consuming process, given the complex nature of health systems. But, there are things we can do right away to get things moving. We don’t have to wait for full implementation of NHI.

The current District Health Programme Grant can be expanded to enable provinces to increase primary healthcare services. The grant currently focuses on resourcing the country’s response to HIV, which seems to have reached a plateau with fewer people initiated on treatment. Contracting in private providers using this grant could improve service accessibility for testing, reproductive health services and routine healthcare for the working poor. Indeed, contracting in non-state healthcare providers, such as healthcare NGOs, pharmacies, and GPs, can significantly improve the patient experience and help build the public trust that is needed for NHI. As we repurpose the District Health Programme Grant, we can also start building the systems we will need for the district health management offices envisaged under NHI, thus helping to ease the transition when it comes.

The biggest immediate opportunity however lies in improving the accessibility and acceptability of district health services for the working poor. A study by the Bureau of Market Research at UNISA estimated that around 75% of working people in South Africa earn less than R6 000 a month. The current structure of publicly funded primary healthcare services do not respond to their routine needs, which include accessing family planning, seeing a GP when ill, a dentist to address oral health issues or access to rehab services. Apart from meeting the needs of these people, expanding service points, particularly in urban areas, can also improve disease surveillance through increased testing, and increased uptake of HIV prevention and treatment services.

There are more areas where we can make progress now that will ease the transition to NHI. For example, the current National Tertiary Services Grant, with an allocation of R15 billion, can be used to support a deep dive into what services our hospitals offer, what resources they are allocated and why, and how all of that lines up with the health need in our districts. The data isn’t currently there to really know whether we are getting value for money from our public hospitals. As with primary care, we need to get a clearer understanding of the need and start re-engineering the system so that we are in a better position to meet that need as we start implementing NHI.

Ultimately then, it is limiting to think of NHI exclusively as the establishment of a state-run medical aid scheme – as it is often portrayed in the media. A public discourse dominated by debates over the future of medical schemes risks obscuring the substantial potential NHI offers for improving and restructuring how public health services are organised and funded. The reality is that with NHI, we have an opportunity to shift the focus of our healthcare system toward primary healthcare and in the process to make our health system much more efficient and equitable. It is imperative that we do whatever is needed to deliver on that potential.

*Rensburg is Director of the Rural Health Advocacy Project.

Note: Spotlight aims to deepen public understanding of important health issues by publishing a variety of views on its opinion pages. The views expressed in this article are not necessarily shared by the Spotlight editors.

Republished from Spotlight under a Creative Commons licence.

Read the original article

New Blood Test on a Chip Rapidly Detects Earliest Signs of Heart Attack

Peng Zheng shows off the heart of the blood test, chip with a groundbreaking nanostructured surface on which blood is tested. Image: Will Kirk / Johns Hopkins University

With heart attacks, every second counts. A newly developed blood test on a chip diagnoses them in minutes rather than hours and could be adapted as a tool for first responders and people at home.

“Heart attacks require immediate medical intervention in order to improve patient outcomes, but while early diagnosis is critical, it can also be very challenging – and near impossible outside of a clinical setting,” said lead author Peng Zheng, an assistant research scientist at Johns Hopkins University. “We were able to invent a new technology that can quickly and accurately establish if someone is having a heart attack.”

The proof-of-concept work, which can be modified to detect infectious diseases and cancer biomarkers, is described in Advanced Science.

Zheng and senior author Ishan Barman develop diagnostic tools through biophotonics, using laser light to detect biomarkers, which are bodily responses to conditions including disease. Here they used the technology to find the earliest signs in the blood that someone was having a heart attack. Heart attacks remain one of the trickiest conditions to diagnose, with symptoms that vary widely and biological signals that can be subtle and easy to miss in the early stages of an attack, when medical intervention can do the most good.

Will be like ‘ Star Trek tricorder’

People suspected of having heart attacks typically are given a combination of tests to confirm the diagnosis – usually starting with electrocardiograms to measure the electrical activity of the heart, a procedure that takes about five minutes, and blood tests to detect the hallmarks of a heart attack, where lab work can take at least an hour and often has to be repeated.

The stand-alone blood test the team created provides results in five to seven minutes. It’s also more accurate and more affordable than current methods, the researchers say.

Though created for speedy diagnostic work in a clinical setting, the test could be adapted as a hand-held tool that first responders could use in the field, or that people might even be able to use themselves at home.

“We’re talking about speed, we’re talking about accuracy, and we’re talking of the ability to perform measurements outside of a hospital,” said Barman, a bioengineer in JHU’s Department of Mechanical Engineering. “In the future we hope this could be made into a hand-held instrument like a Star Trek tricorder, where you have a drop of blood and then, voilà, in a few seconds you have detection.”

The heart of the invention is a tiny chip with a groundbreaking nanostructured surface on which blood is tested. The chip’s “metasurface” enhances electric and magnetic signals during Raman spectroscopy analysis, making heart attack biomarkers visible in seconds, even in ultra-low concentrations. The tool is sensitive enough to flag heart attack biomarkers that might not be detected at all with current tests, or not detected until much later in an attack.

Though designed to diagnose heart attacks, the tool could be adapted to detect cancer and infectious diseases, the researchers say.

“There is enormous commercial potential,” Barman said. “There’s nothing that limits this platform technology.”

Next the team plans to refine the blood test and explore larger clinical trials.

Source: John Hopkins University

The Search for an Effective Treatment for Glaucoma

Photo by Ksenia Chernaya

Pete Williams at Karolinska Institutet is one of the few researchers in Sweden concentrating on glaucoma. The goal is an effective treatment, something that stops the degenerative process in the nerve cells of the eye. He is the senior author of a new paper in Nature Communications on how deficiency of the enzyme NMNAT2 renders the nerve cells of the eye vulnerable to neurodegeneration and could be a key in the search for a treatment. 

Glaucoma is very common. Eighty million people worldwide have the eye disease. There is no cure, but there are treatments that lower the pressure in the eye and that can slow down the progression of the disease, which otherwise leads to irreversible blindness.

Not always treatable

“Most people who have heard of glaucoma believe that it can be treated with eye drops and surgery. Unfortunately, this is not entirely true. For many of the patients, the treatment lower the eye pressure but doesn’t prevent further vision loss,” says Pete Williams.

Knowledge about glaucoma has taken time to develop because the disease progresses slowly. This means that in the past, it took many years before researchers could see if a particular treatment had any effect. However, in the last decade or so, the availability of instruments that measure changes in the eye much earlier than the patient experiences them has given new impetus to research into the eye disease.

The importance of NAD

In the 1980s, research into neurodegenerative diseases discovered a link with NAD, a co-enzyme, ie a molecule that binds to an enzyme and makes it active.  Pete Williams’ group was the first to show that NAD levels were low in animal models of glaucoma.

“NAD has many important functions in the body. A lack of it is important for neuronal health and survival in many diseases, but we don’t yet know how to use this information to create a better treatment ” says Pete Williams.

When the body makes NAD, it uses an enzyme NMNAT1. However, in neurons, it needs another enzyme: NMNAT2 (which is only found in neurons). 

“In our recent paper in Nature Communications, we show that NMNAT2 is needed to protect neurons in the eye and that gene therapy can be used to increase levels,” says Pete Willams. “

The research team is now moving on to try to develop new substances that target NMNAT2 in nerve cells. 

Source: Karolinksa Institutet

Aerobic Exercise may Help Prevent the Brain Fog from Chemotherapy

Clinical trial reveals improved self-reported cognitive function in women with breast cancer who started an exercise program when initiating chemotherapy.

Photo by Ketut Subiyanto on Pexels

Many women who receive chemotherapy experience a decreased ability to remember, concentrate, and/or think – commonly referred to as “chemo-brain” or “brain fog” – both short- and long-term. In a recent clinical trial of women initiating chemotherapy for breast cancer, those who simultaneously started an aerobic exercise program self-reported greater improvements in cognitive function and quality of life compared with those receiving standard care. The findings are published by Wiley online in CANCER, a peer-reviewed journal of the American Cancer Society.

The study, called the Aerobic exercise and CogniTIVe functioning in women with breAsT cancEr (ACTIVATE) trial, included 57 Canadian women in Ottawa and Vancouver who were diagnosed with stage I–III breast cancer and beginning chemotherapy. All women participated in 12–24 weeks of aerobic exercise: 28 started this exercise when initiating chemotherapy and 29 started after chemotherapy completion. Cognitive function assessments were conducted before chemotherapy initiation and after chemotherapy completion (therefore, before the latter group started the exercise program).

Women who participated in the aerobic exercise program during chemotherapy self-reported better cognitive functioning and felt their mental abilities improved compared with those who received standard care without exercise. Neuropsychological testing – a performance-based method used to measure a range of mental functions – revealed similar cognitive performance in the two groups after chemotherapy completion, however.

“Our findings strengthen the case for making exercise assessment, recommendation, and referral a routine part of cancer care; this may help empower women living with and beyond cancer to actively manage both their physical and mental health during and after treatment,” said lead author Jennifer Brunet, PhD, of the University of Ottawa.

Dr Brunet noted that many women undergoing chemotherapy for breast cancer remain insufficiently active, and there are limited exercise programs tailored to their needs. “To address this, we advocate for collaboration across various sectors – academic, healthcare, fitness, and community – to develop exercise programs specifically designed for women with breast cancer,” she said. “These programs should be easy to adopt and implement widely, helping to make the benefits of exercise more accessible to all women facing the challenges of cancer treatment and recovery.”

Source: Wiley

How Muscle Energy Production is Impaired in Type 2 Diabetes

Mitochondria (red) are organelles found in most cells. They generate a cell’s chemical energy. Credit: NICHD/U. Manor

A new study from Karolinska Institutet, published in Science Translational Medicine, shows that people with type 2 diabetes have lower levels of the protein that breaks down and converts creatine in the muscles. This leads to impaired function of the mitochondria, the ‘powerhouses’ of the cell.

Creatine is a popular supplement for improving exercise performance as it can make muscles work harder and longer before they become fatigued. Previous studies however showed a possible link between high blood creatine levels and increased type 2 diabetes risk. This has raised questions about whether creatine supplementation may contribute to that risk.

New research based on studies in both humans and mice shows that people with type 2 diabetes have lower protein levels in their muscles that metabolises and converts creatine – a protein called creatine kinase. 

“This reduced protein level leads to impaired creatine metabolism in the muscle. This may explain why people with type 2 diabetes accumulate creatine in their blood,” says principal investigator Anna Krook, Professor at the Department of Physiology and Pharmacology at Karolinska Institutet.

Scientists don’t know exactly what high creatine levels in the blood mean for the body, but it is known that it does have an effect outside the cells. 

“The findings indicate that impaired creatine metabolism is a consequence of type 2 diabetes, rather than a cause of the disease,” says Anna Krook. 

Impairs mitochondrial function

The study also shows that low levels of creatine kinase are not only linked to higher creatine levels in the blood, but also impair the function of mitochondria in the muscle. Mitochondria, which convert nutrients into energy, function less well in muscle cells with reduced creatine kinase, leading to both lower energy production and increased cell stress.

“This is quite consistent with the fact that people with type 2 diabetes have poorer energy metabolism. In the future, one possibility could be to regulate creatine kinase as part of the treatment of metabolic diseases such as obesity and diabetes,” says Anna Krook.

An unexpected finding of the study was that changes in creatine kinase levels affected the appearance of mitochondria and also their ability to produce energy, regardless of the amount of creatine available. 

“This suggests that although the main role of creatine kinase is to process creatine, it affects mitochondrial function in other ways,” explains David Rizo-Roca, the study’s first author.

“Our next step is to find the molecular mechanisms behind these effects,” he says. 

Source: Karolinska Institutet

Immunotherapy Blocks Scarring, Improves Cardiac Function in Heart Failure

Right side heart failure. Credit: Scientific Animations CC4.0

A new study from Washington University School of Medicine in St. Louis suggests that a type of immunotherapy also may be an effective treatment strategy for heart failure by using an FDA-approved drug to block the signalling protein IL-1 beta. The study is published in Nature.

After a heart attack, viral infection or other injury to the heart, scar tissue often forms in the heart muscle, where it interferes with the heart’s normal contractions and plays a leading role in heart failure, a chronic condition which can only be slowed, not cured.

Studying human tissue samples as part of the new study, the researchers identified a type of fibroblast cell in the heart as the main culprit responsible for the formation of scar tissue in heart failure. To see if they could prevent scar formation, the scientists turned to mouse models of heart failure that have the very same type of fibroblasts. They used a therapeutic monoclonal antibody that blocks the formation of this harmful type of fibroblast, and succeeded in reducing the formation of scar tissue and improving heart function in the mice.

“After scar tissue forms in the heart, its ability to recover is dramatically impaired or impossible,” said cardiologist and senior author Kory Lavine, MD, PhD, a professor of medicine in the Cardiovascular Division at WashU Medicine. “Heart failure is a growing problem in the US and globally, affecting millions of people. Current treatments can help relieve symptoms and slow the progression, but there is a tremendous need for better therapies that actually stop the disease process and prevent the formation of new scar tissue that causes a loss of heart function. We are hopeful our study will lead to clinical trials investigating this immunotherapy strategy in heart failure patients.”

Fibroblasts have many roles in the heart, and parsing out the differences between various populations of these cells has been challenging. Some types of fibroblasts support the heart’s structural integrity and maintain good blood flow through the heart’s blood vessels, while others are responsible for driving inflammation and the development of scar tissue. Only recently, with the wide availability of the most advanced single cell sequencing technologies, could scientists peg which groups of cells are which.

“These various types of fibroblasts highlight newly recognised opportunities to craft treatment strategies that specifically block the type of fibroblasts that promote scarring and protect fibroblasts that maintain the structure of the heart, so the heart doesn’t rupture,” Lavine said. “Our research suggests that the fibroblasts that promote scarring in the injured heart are very similar to fibroblasts associated with cancer and other inflammatory processes. This opens the door to immunotherapies that potentially can stop the inflammation and resulting scar tissue.”

The research team, co-led by Junedh Amrute, a graduate student in Lavine’s lab, used genetic methods to demonstrate that a signaling molecule called IL-1 beta was important in a chain of events driving fibroblasts to create scar tissue in heart failure. With that in mind, they tested a mouse monoclonal antibody that blocks IL-1 beta and found beneficial effects in the mouse hearts. The mouse monoclonal antibody was provided by Amgen, whose scientists were also co-authors of the study. Monoclonal antibodies are proteins manufactured in the lab that modulate the immune system. The treatment reduced the formation of scar tissue and improved the pumping capacity of the mouse hearts, as measured on an echocardiogram.

At least two FDA-approved monoclonal antibodies, canakinumab and rilonacept, can block IL-1 signalling. These immunotherapies are approved to treat inflammatory disorders such as juvenile idiopathic arthritis and recurrent pericarditis, which is inflammation of the sac surrounding the heart.

One of these antibodies also has been evaluated in a clinical trial for atherosclerosis, a buildup of plaque that hardens the arteries. The trial, called CANTOS (Canakinumab Anti-inflammatory Thrombosis Outcome Study), showed a benefit for study participants with atherosclerosis.

“Even though this trial was not designed to test this treatment in heart failure, there are hints in the data that the monoclonal antibody might be beneficial for patients with heart failure,” Lavine said. “Secondary analyses of the data from this trial showed that the treatment was associated with a sizable reduction in heart failure admissions compared with standard care. Our new study may help explain why.”

Even so, the IL-1 antibody used in the CANTOS study had some side effects, such as increased risk of infection, that could perhaps be reduced with a more targeted antibody that specifically blocks IL-1 signaling in cardiac fibroblasts, according to the researchers.

“We are hopeful that the combination of all of this evidence, including our work on the IL-1 beta pathway, will lead to the design of a clinical trial to specifically test the role of targeted immunotherapy in heart failure patients,” Lavine said.

Source: Washington University School of Medicine

New Discovery Explains How SARS-CoV-2 Evades Anti-viral Immunity

Image by Fusion Medical on Unsplash

The novel coronavirus SARS-CoV-2 has an enzyme that can counteract a cell’s innate defence mechanism against viruses, explaining why it is more infectious than the previous SARS and MERS-causing viruses. This discovery, from Kobe University, may point the way to the development of more effective drugs against this and possibly similar, future diseases.

When a virus attacks, the body’s immune response has two basic layers of defence: the innate and the adaptive immune systems. While the adaptive immune system grows stronger against a specific pathogen as the body is exposed to it multiple times and which forms the basis of vaccinations, the innate immune system is an assortment of molecular mechanisms that work against a broad range of pathogens at a basic level. The Kobe University virologist SHOJI Ikuo says, “The new coronavirus, however, is so infectious that we wondered what clever mechanisms the virus employs to evade the innate immune system so effectively.”

Shoji’s team previously worked on the immune response to hepatitis viruses and investigated the role of a molecular tag called “ISG15” the innate immune system attaches to the virus’s building blocks. Having learned that the novel coronavirus has an enzyme that is especially effective in removing this tag, he decided to use his team’s expertise to elucidate the effect of the ISG15 tag on the coronavirus and the mechanism of the virus’s countermeasures.

In a paper in the Journal of Virology, the Kobe University-led team is now the first to report that the ISG15 tag gets attached to a specific location on the virus’s nucleocapsid protein, the scaffold that packages the pathogen’s genetic material. For the virus to assemble, many copies of the nucleocapsid protein need to attach to each other, but the ISG15 tag prevents this, which is the mechanism behind the tag’s antiviral action. “However, the novel coronavirus also has an enzyme that can remove the tags from its nucleocapsid, recovering its ability to assemble new viruses and thus overcoming the innate immune response,” explains Shoji.

The novel coronavirus shares many traits with the SARS and MERS viruses, which all belong to the same family of viruses – which also have an enzyme that can remove the ISG15 tag. But their versions are less efficient at it than the one in the novel coronavirus, Shoji’s team found. And in fact, it has been reported recently that the previous viruses’ enzymes have a different primary target. “These results suggest that the novel coronavirus is simply better at evading this aspect of the innate immune system’s defence mechanism, which explains why it is so infectious,” says Shoji.

But understanding just why the novel coronavirus is so effective also points the way to developing more effective treatments. The Kobe University researcher explains: “We may be able to develop new antiviral drugs if we can inhibit the function of the viral enzyme that removes the ISG15 tag. Future therapeutic strategies may also include antiviral agents that directly target the nucleocapsid protein, or a combination of these two approaches.”

Source: Kobe University

Men and Women Use Different Biological Systems to Reduce Pain

Photo by Sasun Bughdaryan on Unsplash

In a new study evaluating meditation for chronic lower back pain, researchers at University of California San Diego School of Medicine have discovered that men and women utilise different biological systems to relieve pain. While men relieve pain by releasing endogenous opioids, the body’s natural painkillers, women rely instead on other, non-opioid based pathways. The study was published in PNAS Nexus.

Synthetic opioid drugs, such as morphine and fentanyl, are the most powerful class of painkilling drugs available. Women are known to respond poorly to opioid therapies, which use synthetic opioid molecules to bind to the same receptors as naturally-occurring endogenous opioids. This aspect of opioid drugs helps explain why they are so powerful as painkillers, but also why they carry a significant risk of dependence and addiction.

“Dependence develops because people start taking more opioids when their original dosage stops working,” said Fadel Zeidan, PhD, professor of anaesthesiology and Endowed Professor in Empathy and Compassion Research at UC San Diego Sanford Institute for Empathy and Compassion. “Although speculative, our findings suggest that maybe one reason that females are more likely to become addicted to opioids is that they’re biologically less responsive to them and need to take more to experience any pain relief.”

The study combined data from two clinical trials involving a total of 98 participants, including both healthy individuals and those diagnosed with chronic lower back pain. Participants underwent a meditation training program, then practiced meditation while receiving either placebo or a high-dose of naloxone, a drug that stops both synthetic and endogenous opioids from working. At the same time, they experienced a very painful but harmless heat stimulus to the back of the leg. The researchers measured and compared how much pain relief was experienced from meditation when the opioid system was blocked versus when it was intact.

The study found:

  • Blocking the opioid system with naloxone inhibited meditation-based pain relief in men, suggesting that men rely on endogenous opioids to reduce pain.
  • Naloxone increased meditation-based pain relief in women, suggesting that women rely on non-opioid mechanisms to reduce pain.
  • In both men and women, people with chronic pain experienced more pain relief from meditation than healthy participants.

“These results underscore the need for more sex-specific pain therapies, because many of the treatments we use don’t work nearly as well for women as they do for men,” said Zeidan.

The researchers conclude that by tailoring pain treatment to an individual’s sex, it may be possible to improve patient outcomes and reduce the reliance on and misuse of opioids.

“There are clear disparities in how pain is managed between men and women, but we haven’t seen a clear biological difference in the use of their endogenous systems before now,” said Zeidan. “This study provides the first clear evidence that sex-based differences in pain processing are real and need to be taken more seriously when developing and prescribing treatment for pain.”

Source: University of California – San Diego

Epstein-Barr Virus: How does a Common Infection Trick the Immune System into Attacking the Brain in People with MS?

An electron micrograph showing three Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) particles colourised red-orange. Credit: NIAID

Olivia Thomas, Karolinska Institutet; Graham Taylor, University of Birmingham, and Jill Brooks, University of Birmingham

Almost 3 million people worldwide have multiple sclerosis (MS) – an autoimmune disease caused by the immune system mistakenly attacking the brain and central nervous system.

While treatments for MS have improved over the years, there’s still no cure. This is largely because researchers still don’t fully understand what goes wrong in the immune system to cause MS. But our latest research has revealed new insights into the way certain immune cells behave in people with MS. This discovery brings us closer to understanding why some people get MS – and may also be a crucial step in developing better treatments and even cures.

Although the causes of MS aren’t fully understood, we know that genetics, lifestyle and environment factors can all influence MS risk. But the biggest risk factor for developing MS appears to be a common virus called Epstein-Barr virus (EBV).

EBV typically infects people during childhood without causing any symptoms – so most early infections go unnoticed. But if the infection occurs during adolescence, it may cause glandular fever (infectious mononucleosis) which, although debilitating in the short-term, usually has no long-term effects.

Most viral infections are rapidly cleared by the body’s immune system, but EBV is cleverer than most viruses. Although the immune system controls the infection, it is unable to completely eradicate the virus as it hides inside a type of immune cell called a B cell (which normally produce antibodies that bind to and destroy invading viruses or bacteria). Once you’re infected with EBV you carry it for life – although for most people this causes no problems.

By adulthood about 95% of people are infected with EBV, but in people with MS nearly 100% are infected. Large epidemiological studies have shown that EBV infection increases the risk of developing MS over 30-fold. For people who have had glandular fever the risk is even higher. Research has also shown that in people with MS, EBV infection occurs before the very earliest stages of disease.

Many researchers now believe being infected with EBV is more than a risk factor in MS – it’s essential.

But how does EBV cause MS – and why does a common virus only cause MS in a few people? Several theories are currently being investigated.

One theory is that in some people the immune cells activated by EBV mistakenly attack parts of the brain and central nervous system. This process, called molecular mimicry, also occurs in other autoimmune diseases, such as Guillain-Barré syndrome. This could explain why drugs which prevent immune cells from entering the brain are shown to dramatically improve MS symptoms.

Research into EBV molecular mimicry in MS has mainly focused on the viral protein EBNA1. Without EBNA1 EBV cannot live in B cells, and MS patients have higher levels of antibodies towards EBNA1.

But EBV makes over 80 different proteins during its life cycle. In our latest work we investigated immune responses to these other viral proteins in people with MS.

Altered immunity

We compared the immune responses of 31 people with MS, 33 healthy people and 11 people who had recently recovered from glandular fever. We wanted to see if each group reacted to EBV infections differently.

We found that antibodies targeting EBNA1 and another viral protein called VCA were higher in people with MS compared to the other groups. People with MS were also more likely to have antibodies targeting several other viral proteins. This suggests EBV antibodies are more altered in MS than previously thought – but it isn’t certain whether these antibodies are fighting infection or if they have a role in MS disease.

Scanning electron micrograph of a T cell lymphocyte. Credit: NIH / NIAID

Antibodies aren’t the full story. Previous research has suggested another type of immune cell, called a T cell, may also play an important role as they’re found in high numbers in MS brain lesions. As such, we wanted to understand whether T cells which fight EBV were different in people with MS.

By analysing blood samples we found that, although EBV T cell numbers were similar in MS and healthy people, these cells behaved differently in people with MS. T cells from people with MS produced slightly higher amounts of an inflammatory substance called interleukin-2. The body normally produces this substance in response to injury or infection, but too much interleukin-2 can cause chronic disease.

We also looked at molecular mimicry, wondering whether EBV T-cells mistakenly target brain proteins rather than fighting the virus.

Surprisingly, we found that in both people with MS and healthy people, their EBV T cells reacted to multiple proteins found in the brain. Notably, most people had EBV T cells that targeted a protein called myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein, or Mog, which surrounds the nerves.

Looking at one person with MS in more detail, we found individual T cells that directly recognised both EBNA1 and Mog. This means that, rather than just fighting infection, some EBV T cells could also target nerve cells in the brain.

This widespread misdirection between EBV T cells and the brain goes some way to suggest how infection with this common virus can lead to MS. But its presence in healthy people is slightly confusing. One possible explanation could be that EBV T cells are better able to cross the blood-brain barrier (a tight-knit lining of cells that protect the brain) in people with MS. This idea is something we’re keen to explore in future research.

While there’s still much we don’t know about these misdirected EBV T cells in the brain, our latest findings provide fresh evidence for researchers and hopefully will lead to the development of new, targeted treatments for MS.

Olivia Thomas, Assistant Professor, Department of Clinical Neuroscience, Karolinska Institutet; Graham Taylor, Associate Professor in Viral and Tumour Immunology, University of Birmingham, and Jill Brooks, Research Fellow, Institute of Cancer and Genomic Sciences, University of Birmingham

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Opinion Piece: Prioritising Healthcare Access for All Employees Makes Sound Business Sense

By Reo Botes, Managing Executive at Essential Employee Benefits

22 October 2024

South African businesses operate in an environment in which many employees, particularly those in lower income segments, struggle to afford basic healthcare services. Healthcare benefits like medical aid are simply not affordable for the majority of the workforce, even if they are subsidised, which exacerbates the existing dichotomy. Addressing this issue should be a strategic imperative as well as a matter of ethical compliance and social responsibility.

While executives play a crucial role in setting strategy, many layers of employees are operationally required to fulfil said strategy. Keeping all layers of employees healthy by promoting access to quality healthcare, boosts both sustainability and competitiveness. We dare not wait for the National Health Insurance (NHI) to come into effect to solve this challenge; we have a responsibility to make private healthcare more accessible, and one way that companies can do this is by incorporating affordable health insurance products into their employee benefits basket.

A legacy of inequality

The legacy of apartheid has left an indelible mark on South Africa’s socio-economic landscape. This is reflected in the persistent inequality that permeates many facets of life, including significant disparities between rural and urban areas, as well as access to healthcare. Decades later, private healthcare remains predominantly accessible to the wealthy, while the majority of South Africans are left to rely on an overburdened public health system.

Medical aid has been the traditional path to affordably accessing private healthcare, but the premiums remain out of reach for the lower income earners, even if companies subsidise the cost. The lower-cost medical aid options have struggled to get off the ground, and the effective rollout of the NHI will take many years to come to fruition. Since most people cannot afford medical aid and cannot rely on universal access to public healthcare, there needs to be another option that will enable them to access healthcare affordably. Making health insurance benefits available with options that suit different income segments will not only help to address this issue, but it will also benefit businesses as well.

A healthy workforce just makes business sense

From a legal standpoint, South African companies are bound by the Labour Relations Act and the Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHSA), both of which mandate the provision of a safe and healthy working environment. While these regulations primarily focus on workplace safety, the concept of a healthy workplace extends beyond physical safety to encompass the overall well-being of employees. Ethical governance demands that companies do more than the bare minimum required by law; it requires a proactive approach to employee welfare.

Beyond ethical and compliance concerns, having a healthy workforce is simply good for business. Healthy employees are more likely to be engaged, motivated, and productive, which in turn contributes to the overall success of the business. Moreover, a company that invests in the health of its workforce is likely to see a return on investment (ROI) through reduced turnover, lower absenteeism, and higher employee satisfaction.

By offering health insurance benefits that are tailored to the needs of employees across different income brackets, companies can demonstrate a genuine commitment to their employees’ well-being. This not only fosters trust and loyalty among the workforce but also enhances the company’s reputation as an employer of choice.

Health insurance for all, not just for executives

Photo by Emmanuel Ikwuegbe on Unsplash

Budget constraints are often cited as a major barrier when it comes to subsidising healthcare costs, but health insurance products aimed at lower income segments are a fraction of the cost of the more comprehensive medical aid products offered to executive tiers, and the cost-benefit ratio of providing greater access to healthcare services can be profound. When employees have access to health insurance, they can seek medical attention promptly, reducing the likelihood of prolonged illness and absenteeism, which in turn are detrimental to business.

Even if businesses, particularly small and medium-sized enterprises, cannot afford to subsidise health insurance products, they can still offer access to them as part of employee benefits. Companies can negotiate group rates for health insurance on behalf of their employees, making it more affordable than taking out a policy on their own and thus reducing the cost without the need to subsidise. Aligning health insurance benefits with employee needs and income levels ensures that the cover is both relevant and accessible and supports long-term business goals by promoting a healthier, more resilient employee base.

Change comes from the top

Human Resources (HR) and executive leadership play a pivotal role in the implementation of inclusive health insurance benefits. While executives are responsible for setting the overall strategy, it is the HR teams that must operationalise these strategies and ensure they are effectively communicated and implemented across the organisation. This includes understanding the diverse needs of the workforce, negotiating with insurance providers, and designing benefits packages that are both affordable and impactful.

By integrating health insurance into the broader employee value proposition, companies can enhance their appeal to top talent, including high performers in lower income brackets. A comprehensive benefits package that includes health insurance is a key differentiator in a competitive job market, helping companies attract and retain skilled workers who are critical to executing business strategies.

Inclusivity drives resilience

Ultimately, the provision of health insurance benefits for all employees is about building a strong foundation for business success. A healthy, happy, and productive workforce is essential for any company looking to achieve long-term sustainability and growth. By taking care of their employees’ health, companies are not only doing the right thing from an ethical standpoint but are also making a smart business decision that will pay dividends in terms of productivity, employee retention, and overall organisational resilience.

South African companies must recognise the importance of inclusive health insurance benefits as a critical component of their business strategy. Addressing the historical inequalities in healthcare access, meeting legal and ethical obligations, and investing in the health and well-being of all employees are essential steps towards building a more equitable and prosperous future for both businesses and their workforce. Businesses can play a pivotal role as the country continues to grapple with the challenges of inequality and healthcare access.