Category: Expert Opinion

Opinion Piece: Mitigate Risks and Enhance Efficiency – the ISO Accreditation Advantage

Photo by Scott Graham on Unsplash

By Robert Erasmus, Managing Director at Sanitech

ISO accreditation is a strategic investment that empowers businesses to enhance their competitiveness, mitigate risks, and seize new market opportunities. By adhering to globally recognised standards, organisations can build trust, streamline operations, and achieve sustainable growth. While the initial outlay may seem substantial, the long-term returns in terms of efficiency, customer satisfaction, and regulatory compliance far exceed the costs.

Building credibility and adherence to global standards

In today’s increasingly globalised business landscape, standing out from the competition is essential. ISO accreditation acts as a powerful endorsement, signifying a company’s commitment to quality, efficiency, and adherence to international best practices. By obtaining ISO certification, businesses can better mitigate risk while demonstrating their credibility and reliability to customers, suppliers, and stakeholders alike. 

How ISO standards provide a framework for best practices

ISO standards provide a structured approach to managing various aspects of an organisation’s operations, ensuring consistent performance and compliance with customer and regulatory expectations. These standards offer a comprehensive framework that guides companies in identifying, managing, and continually improving their processes, which ultimately provides an effective means of identifying and managing risk throughout the business. Here’s a brief breakdown of how specific ISO standards contribute to this:

ISO 9001: Quality Management System

  • Customer focus: Defines processes to understand customer needs and expectations, ensuring products or services meet or exceed these requirements. 
  • Process-based approach: Establishes a systematic approach to identifying, managing, and controlling processes to achieve desired outcomes. 
  • Continuous improvement: Promotes a culture of continual improvement by monitoring processes, identifying opportunities for enhancement, and implementing changes.

ISO 14001: Environmental Management System

  • Environmental Impact Assessment: Requires organisations to identify, assess, and control environmental impacts of their activities. 
  • Legal compliance: Ensures adherence to environmental laws and regulations. 
  • Resource efficiency: Promotes the efficient use of resources and waste reduction. 
  • Stakeholder engagement: Encourages dialogue with stakeholders to address environmental concerns.

ISO 22000: Food Safety Management System

  • Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Points (HACCP): Implements a systematic approach to identifying, assessing, and controlling food safety hazards. 
  • Supply chain management: Addresses food safety throughout the entire supply chain. 
  • Regulatory compliance: Ensures compliance with food safety regulations and standards. 

ISO 45001: Occupational Health and Safety Management System

  • Risk assessment: Identifies and assesses occupational health and safety risks. 
  • Legal compliance: Ensures compliance with occupational health and safety legislation. 
  • Emergency preparedness: Develops and implements emergency procedures. 
  • Employee involvement: Encourages employee participation in health and safety initiatives. 

ISO standards incorporate several fundamental elements to ensure consistent performance and improvement. These include the Plan-Do-Check-Act (PDCA) cycle for continuous enhancement, robust risk management practices, comprehensive documentation, regular internal and external audits to assess effectiveness, as well as periodic management reviews to evaluate overall performance and identify areas for improvement. By adopting these standards, organisations can leverage this robust framework for managing their operations, ensuring consistent performance, which positions the organisation to be able to meet the evolving needs of customers and regulatory authorities.

The benefits of working with ISO-certified suppliers

Choosing ISO-certified suppliers can significantly enhance a business’s supply chain resilience. This choice gives companies the peace of mind that their new suppliers adhere to rigorous standards, which ensures improved product and service quality, as ISO certification guarantees consistent product or service quality, reducing the risk of defects or errors.

There is also a reduction in the risk of non-compliance, as ISO-certified suppliers have robust systems in place to manage compliance with regulatory requirements, mitigating legal and financial risks. Additionally, ISO accreditation promotes efficient operations and well-documented processes lead to smoother collaboration and predictable outcomes. In short, partnering with ISO-certified suppliers strengthens a company’s supply chain reputation, inspiring trust among customers.

The bottom line of ISO accreditation

While the initial costs of ISO accreditation may be substantial, the long-term benefits are undeniable. By investing in ISO certification, businesses can enhance their credibility, improve operational efficiency, mitigate risks, and gain a competitive edge. Just as important, working with ISO-certified suppliers strengthens a company’s supply chain, ensuring the delivery of high-quality products and services. This in turn leads to increased customer satisfaction, loyalty, and business growth. 

As such, ISO accreditation is not merely a compliance exercise; it is a strategic investment that empowers businesses to thrive in today’s challenging market. By understanding the value of different ISO standards and the advantages of working with ISO-certified suppliers, companies can make informed decisions to drive sustainable success.

From Bottlenecks to Breakthroughs: BHF Report Charts the Course for Southern Africa’s Healthcare Future

Photo by Hush Naidoo on Unsplash

By adopting bold, transformative strategies, the healthcare industry can overcome critical challenges and foster innovative collaborations to create a more equitable and sustainable healthcare future for southern Africa, writes Dr Katlego Mothudi, Managing Director at the Board of Healthcare Funders (BHF).

Committed to promoting collaboration and creating actionable insights within southern Africa’s healthcare ecosystem, BHF’s recently published report highlights significant trends, obstacles and breakthrough solutions from key figures in the healthcare sector, and charts the course for a robust, inclusive healthcare future. 

By interviewing industry leaders – including funders, hospitals, clinicians, and the pharmaceutical sector – the report presents a strategic path forward that promises to revolutionise the region’s healthcare landscape. As southern Africa grapples with rising healthcare costs, a growing burden of non-communicable diseases (NCDs), and economic instability, this report charts the course for a robust, inclusive healthcare future.

The evolving landscape of southern African healthcare

Healthcare organisations in southern Africa are navigating a complex landscape filled with escalating challenges and promising opportunities. The rapid increase in the burden of non-communicable diseases (NCDs) and economic volatility is driving a critical shift toward more sustainable healthcare models while increasing healthcare costs and reducing affordability. 

Concurrently, there is a renewed commitment to achieving health equity, with concerted efforts to ensure healthcare is universally accessible. Universal Health Coverage (UHC) is in various stages of rollout across the region, reflecting varying national priorities and capabilities. In South Africa, the proposed National Health Insurance (NHI), despite its controversies, is being closely watched for its potential impact on other countries if implemented pragmatically.

In the private sector, the health insurance market shows notable growth. This is in contrast to stagnation relating to traditional medical schemes. These schemes face slow or no membership growth and rising utilisation rates, pushing a gradual shift towards value-based care with strategies to strengthen contracting arrangements, control expenditure and improve health outcomes. 

High levels of fraud, waste and abuse persist, particularly in southern Africa, where economic conditions have severely limited the growth of private health insurance or medical scheme coverage, highlighting the critical need for innovative healthcare financing solutions.

Additionally, the post-COVID acceleration of digital healthcare is gradually reshaping service delivery. Significant investments in artificial intelligence and predictive analytics are set to strengthen health risk management, boost patient care and enhance operational efficiency. 

This era of digital transformation is marked by collaborations with local and global tech innovators and a strategic internal focus on tech integration to overhaul legacy systems and traditional practices. This complex tapestry of trends indicates a critical juncture for the region’s healthcare, laden with challenges, yet rich with opportunities for pioneering change.

Bottlenecks and barriers

Southern Africa’s healthcare systems face significant barriers to sustainability, including inefficient and politicised regulatory environments, inadequate workforce training, economic instability and the growing corporatisation of healthcare, all of which hinder innovation, affordability and access while threatening both public trust and the quality of care.

Reactive responses to emerging challenges

In response to the bottlenecks and challenges facing the sector, healthcare organisations across southern Africa are collaborating with government and business coalitions, such as Business for South Africa, to address fiscal risks and policy uncertainties, and promote private sector participation, regulatory harmonisation and advanced technologies. 

They are prioritising integrated healthcare models focused on primary care and value-based approaches, investing in digital innovations such as telemedicine, electronic health records and AI to improve efficiency and outcomes. Efforts to optimise resource allocation and care quality through digitalisation and process reengineering are also underway. 

While these actions address immediate challenges, longer-term systemic solutions are necessary to achieve UHC and future-proof their markets.

Proactive systemic responses

To create a sustainable and equitable healthcare environment in southern Africa, long-term strategic solutions are essential, and aimed at broadening healthcare access, enhancing system efficiency and ensuring financial sustainability. 

To achieve UHC, access through a multi-payer system that guarantees quality, affordable healthcare for all is instrumental. Implementing UHC principles will promote preventative care, care coordination, and effective management of chronic diseases. Additionally, advancing public-private partnerships (PPPs) can significantly enhance access and care quality, with proactive private sector engagement helping to overcome existing barriers and drive progress.

To improve policy and regulation, it is crucial to enhance the oversight and effectiveness of regulatory institutions while fostering regional inclusivity across the Southern African Development Community (SADC) for better knowledge sharing. 

In South Africa, aligning the NHI with a multi-funder framework will integrate private funders and recognise employers’ roles in system sustainability. Updating benefits to reflect current health needs and economic conditions will make healthcare more affordable and less hospital-centric. Introducing Low-Cost Benefit Options (LCBOs) within medical schemes will broaden access, while strengthening competition and optimising private sector performance, will enhance care quality. Additionally, establishing a risk equalisation fund and mandating medical scheme membership is key to stabilising the insurance market and lowering costs.

To advance healthcare, investments in infrastructure and technology are essential, especially in underserved areas, to ensure equitable access. Strengthening healthcare training and updating practice guidelines will improve care quality and expand capabilities, while better workforce planning and collaboration between academia and healthcare providers will align training with industry needs. Additionally, leveraging digital health initiatives, such as telemedicine and electronic health records, will enhance service reach and efficiency.

Furthermore, incorporating Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) principles is crucial for promoting resilience and establishing southern African healthcare systems as leaders in sustainable practices. Adopting ESG standards will enhance the sustainability and governance of these healthcare systems.

These strategies are designed not only to address immediate healthcare challenges, but also to establish a robust foundation for a future where high quality healthcare is universally accessible in southern Africa. By implementing these solutions, the region can bridge the current gaps and pave the way for a resilient healthcare system.

Through collaborative efforts, strategic reforms, and innovative solutions, southern Africa’s healthcare sector is not only meeting current needs but also preparing for future demands that are defined by innovation, equity and sustainability. 

Transforming South Africa’s Healthcare Sector: The Essential Role of Leadership

Dr Ali Hamdulay

By Dr Ali Hamdulay – CEO, Metropolitan Health Corporate

South Africa’s healthcare sector, a sophisticated and ever-changing industry, is central to the health and prosperity of our communities. Its effective operation, however, hinges on the strength and direction of its leadership.

Leadership, given the broad healthcare landscape, is far from a singular role; it’s a complex undertaking that requires comprehensive understanding of the wide medical ambit, the regulatory environment, compassion, and a forward-thinking mindset. Leaders are the primary builders of healthcare infrastructure, moulding it to encourage innovation, prioritise patient-focused care, and maintain the highest ethical standards.

Attracting and retaining skilled healthcare workers is a critical role that leadership in South Africa’s healthcare landscape must play. This includes attracting and retaining a diverse range of healthcare professionals such as doctors, nurses, and specialists. Leaders are responsible for creating a conducive work environment that not only draws in skilled workers but also motivates them to stay and thrive. Furthermore, leaders are advocates for healthcare workers, ensuring they have the necessary resources and support to carry out their roles effectively.

The rise of technology has ushered in substantial shifts in the healthcare sector. From telemedicine and AI diagnostics to electronic health records, technology has revolutionised how we provide care. Integrating these innovations into the healthcare system, though, is a challenging task that demands visionary leadership.

Leaders must understand these technologies, evaluate their potential advantages and risks, and oversee their implementation in a manner that enhances patient care without jeopardising privacy and security. Teams must also be equipped with the necessary skills to adapt to these changes and effectively implement new procedures.

A pivotal role of a healthcare leader is to champion health equity. Despite progress in healthcare, disparities in access and outcomes remain. Leaders play a crucial role in creating pathways to eradicate these disparities and to ensure that everyone, irrespective of their background, has access to quality healthcare. This involves understanding the social determinants of health, implementing policies that promote equity, and establishing an inclusive and respectful culture within the healthcare environment.

This cannot be done without support.

Leadership isn’t solely about leading; it’s also about inspiring others to lead. By exemplifying excellence and integrity, leaders can inspire their teams to aspire to the same standards. They can cultivate a culture of continuous learning and improvement, encouraging everyone to contribute their ideas and expertise.

A resilient healthcare system is anchored by robust leadership. It requires a mix of knowledge, skills and attitudes, a thorough understanding of the healthcare landscape, the ability to make critical decisions, the vision to embrace innovation, the empathy to advocate for health equity, and the charisma to inspire others.

We must elevate both individual and group thinking within our operating environments if we are to make meaningful progress in establishing a healthcare sector that prioritises access and quality. This approach contributes to a resilient healthcare workforce—one that can adapt to the dynamic landscape and is essential for the sector’s long-term viability and the overall health of South Africa’s population. By embracing this combination of collective and individual thinking, we propel the sector forward across businesses, the healthcare industry, and the nation as a whole.

Navigating the intricacies of the healthcare sector, particularly in the dawn of South Africa’s Government of National Unity, underscores the critical role of strong and reliable leadership. This fresh political landscape brings with it a wave of optimism. It has the potential to catalyse transformative change in our healthcare sector, from policy reforms and resource reallocation to the introduction of initiatives aimed at enhancing healthcare quality.

In our journey towards a more equitable and efficient healthcare system in South Africa, the focus on public-private partnerships must remain steadfast. These partnerships are instrumental in leveraging the strengths of both sectors to deliver better healthcare outcomes. They foster innovation, improve service delivery, and enhance accessibility, making them a crucial component of a robust healthcare system.

During this era of change, leadership is our compass guiding us towards quality access to healthcare for all. The role of leadership in ensuring progress and maintaining stability cannot be overstated. It is the driving force behind a healthcare sector that truly serves its people.

The future of South Africa’s healthcare sector is promising, but it requires the collective effort of all stakeholders. As a business, we recognise the critical role of nurturing our emerging leaders through mentoring and coaching. Our partnerships ensure continuity and preserve the essential skill and knowledge base of our healthcare workforce. These partnerships are key in establishing a healthcare system that is accessible to all and provides quality care.

As we commemorate Nelson Mandela Day, let us honour his unwavering commitment to justice, equality, and compassion. Our responsibility lies not only in the present but also in shaping a legacy for future generations. Let us build a healthcare system that echoes Mandela’s vision—a system that ensures access for all and equips our leaders to carry forth their roles with purpose and resilience.

Building a Culture of Wellness by Fostering a Healthy and Financially Secure Workforce

Photo by RDNE Stock project

By James White, Sales Director at Turnberry Management Risk Solutions

Celebrating Corporate Wellness Awareness Week by highlighting the vital role that companies play in fostering employee health and well-being is not just a matter of timing; it’s a matter of necessity. A healthy workforce is a productive workforce, and a focus on wellness goes beyond just physical health.

This is particularly relevant given that the magnitude of medical expenses has shifted over the years. While common illnesses like influenza pose a threat, the bigger concern lies in hospital stays and unexpected medical procedures. These events can leave employees with significant financial burdens, impacting their well-being and productivity.

The role of employers in mitigating costs

While encouraging healthy lifestyles through fitness programmes and mental health support is vital, ensuring financial security in the face of unforeseen medical expenses is equally important. Employers play a significant role in ensuring their workforce has access to adequate healthcare. Traditionally, medical aid cover has been a common employment benefit, but rising costs have made it less affordable for some employers and their employees. Nevertheless, employers can still help by offering their people assistance through:

  • Understanding medical aid options: A knowledgeable broker can guide employers through the complexities of medical aid options. This includes explaining the benefits, limitations, and potential shortfalls associated with each plan.
  • Considering primary healthcare: For employees who cannot afford comprehensive medical aid, primary healthcare plans are short-term insurance products that offer access to doctors, specialists, and medication, often with capped benefits for private hospital visits.
  • Offering gap cover: Gap cover bridges the gap between medical aid payouts and the actual costs charged by specialists and hospitals, acting as a financial safety net to provide peace of mind for employees facing unforeseen medical expenses.

Common unforeseen medical expenses

  • Hospital stays: These can be particularly expensive, with costs varying depending on the condition and treatment required.
  • Specialist charges: Specialists often charge above the rates covered by medical aid plans, leaving patients with significant bills.
  • Emergency room visits: Even a seemingly minor trip to the ER can result in a hefty bill.

Addressing misconceptions about medical aid

Many employees believe that medical aid offers complete coverage. Brokers can help dispel this myth by explaining the intricacies of the available plan options, such as co-payments, network restrictions, and shortfalls. Some plans limit coverage to specific hospitals or providers, and employees need to be aware of these restrictions to avoid surprise costs, while certain medical aid plans require co-payments for specific procedures or medications, leaving employees with out-of-pocket expenses. Even with medical aid, specialists’ fees often exceed the amount reimbursed and gap cover addresses these shortfalls.

Financial security boosts workplace wellness

By offering (and even subsidising) a combination of medical aid, primary healthcare options, and gap cover, employers can significantly improve the well-being of their people. This is because financial security in the face of medical emergencies will reduce stress and boost morale. Employees with peace of mind regarding healthcare costs are more likely to be happy, productive, and less prone to absenteeism.

However, such assistance is more than simply offering access to such benefits. Employers need to ensure that their workforce can make informed decisions about the healthcare benefits available to them by partnering with a qualified broker. The broker can fulfil a vital educational role by conducting informative workshops to explain medical aid options and limitations and advocate for the value of gap cover.

It makes business sense to invest in a healthy workforce

By prioritising a holistic approach to employee wellness that encompasses both physical and financial health, companies can create a thriving workplace environment. Offering a more comprehensive benefits package that includes access to gap cover demonstrates a commitment to employee well-being, ultimately leading to a happier, healthier, and more productive workforce.

About Turnberry Management Risk Solutions

Founded in 2001, Turnberry is a registered financial services provider (FSP no. 36571) that specialises in Accident and Health Insurance, Travel Insurance, and Funeral Cover.

With extensive experience across healthcare and insurance industries in South Africa, Turnberry offers unsurpassed service to Brokers and clients. Turnberry’s gap cover products are available to clients on all medical aid schemes, as they are independently provided and are therefore transferable in the event of a change in the client’s medical aid scheme.

Turnberry is well represented nationally, with its Head Office based in Bedfordview, Johannesburg with Business Development Managers in Cape Town and Durban. The Turnberry Team’s focus on outstanding client service comes from having extensive knowledge and experience in the financial services sector and is underwritten by Lombard Insurance Company Limited. Lombard Insurance Company Limited is an Authorised Financial Services Provider (FSP 1596) and Insurer conducting non-life insurance business.

Datacentres Form Part of Healthcare Critical Systems – Carrying the Load and so Much More

Photo by Christina Morillo

By Ben Selier, Vice President: Secure Power, Anglophone Africa at Schneider Electric

The adage, knowledge is king couldn’t be more applicable when it comes to the collection and utilisation of data.  And at the heart of this knowledge and resultant information lies the datacentre. Businesses and users count on datacentres, and more so in critical services such as healthcare.

Many hospitals today rely heavily on electronic health records (EHR), and this information resides and is backed up in on-premises datacentres or in the cloud. Datacentres are therefore a major contributor to effective and modernised healthcare.

There are several considerations when designing datacentres for healthcare. For one, hospitals operate within stringent legislation when it comes to the protection of patient information.  The National Health Act (No. 61 of 2003), for example, stipulates that information must not be given to others unless the patient consents or the healthcare practitioner can justify the disclosure.

Datacentres form part of critical systems

To add an extra layer of complexity, in South Africa, datacentres should feature built-in continuous uptime and energy backup due to the country’s unstable power supply.  Hospitals must therefore be designed to be autonomous from the grid, especially when they provide emergency and critical care.

Typically, datacentres are classified in tiers, with the Uptime Institute citing that a Tier-4 datacentre provides 99.995% availability, annual downtime of 0.4 hours, full redundancy, and power outage protection of 96 hours.

In healthcare and when one considers human lives, downtime is simply not an option. And whilst certain healthcare systems and its resultant availability are comparable to a typical Tier-3 or Tier-4 scenario, critical systems in hospitals carry a higher design consideration and must run 24/7 with immediate availability.

In healthcare, the critical infrastructure of a hospital enjoys priority.  What this means is the datacentre is there to protect the IT system which in turn ensures the smooth running of these critical systems and equipment.  There is therefore a delicate balance between the critical systems and infrastructure, and the datacentre, one can’t exist without the other.

Design considerations

To realise the above, hospitals must feature a strong mix of alternative energy resources such as backup generators, uninterrupted power supply (UPS) and renewables such as rooftop solar.

Additionally, like most organisations, storage volume and type and cloud systems will also vary from hospital to hospital. To this end, datacentre design for hospitals is anything but cookie cutter; teams need to work closely with the hospital whilst meeting industry standards for healthcare.

When designing healthcare facilities system infrastructure, the following should also be considered:

  • Software like Building Management Systems (BMS) are not just about building efficiency but also offer benefits such as monitoring and adjusting indoor conditions like temperature control, humidity, and air quality.

The BMS contributes to health and safety and critical operations in hospitals whilst also enabling patient comfort.

  • Maintenance – both building and systems maintenance transcend operational necessity and become a matter of life or death.
  • As mentioned, generators are essential when delivering continuous power which means enough fuel must be stored to run it. Here, hospitals must store fuel safely and in compliance with stringent regulations. In South Africa, proactively managing the refuelling timelines is also critical.  The response times of refuelling these (fuel) bunkers can be severely hindered by issues such as traffic congestion as a result of outages and lights now working.

Selecting the right equipment for hospitals is therefore a delicate balance between technological advancement and safety. For instance, while lithium batteries offer many benefits, when used in hospitals, it is paramount that it is also stored in dry, cool and safe location.

Here, implementing an extinguishing system is a must to alleviate any potential damage from fire or explosions.  That said, lithium batteries are generally considered safe to use but it’s important to be cognisant of its potential safety hazards.

Ultimately, hospitals carry the added weight of human lives which means the design of critical systems require meticulously planning and executed.

Progress, the Unreasonable Man and Technology

Is complementing in-person care with virtual care (hybrid care) a key part of the answer to South Africa’s NHI aspirations, asks Deon Bührs, Managing Director of Genie Health SA, who suggests that technology is the ‘unreasonable man’ in complementing decent universal healthcare and that self-empowerment is the only solution to sustainable wellness.

“The reasonable man adapts himself to the world: the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself. Therefore all progress depends on the unreasonable man.”

George Bernard Shaw

There is a school of thought that a young democracy can benefit from a well-considered blend of socialism and capitalism, particularly when it comes to healthcare and education. I would second that, to a degree.  That South Africa requires a more equitable health system goes without saying though, as the apparent disparity and divisions between the haves and have nots is ever widening.   

The status of our public healthcare system and the spiralling costs of the private offering need to find parity. A sad situation indeed, because at one stage, South Africa had one of the best public health sectors in the world, where groundbreaking heart transplants, for example, were done.

To the question of universal healthcare then. If it means that universal healthcare is a fundamental human right that everyone should aspire to, then it’s a yes, the NHI is essential. It should not be a matter of political affiliation, and let’s be clear, there is already healthcare for all in South Africa, through the public health system, free at the point of care for those who cannot afford care.  But it is the quality of this care, and the effective management of these services that lie in stark contrast to that of the private healthcare system. 

Signed in literally at the 11th hour before the country went to general elections, the National Health Insurance (NHI) bill is a polarising topic for many.  The massive cost of providing a functioning NHI as per the bill, has been estimated conservatively at more than R200 billion a year, while some estimate closer to R1 trillion. With an already strained tax base, we must adopt new thinking as to how to deliver healthcare in a cost sensitive and effective way.

To my mind, one of the most effective ways of ensuring there is universal care that works, is recognising and supporting the role the patient plays in empowering their own health, recovery and wellness journey.  They appear, however, to have been forgotten in the conversation that is the NHI bill to date.

For me, in its current guise, the NHI will unfortunately not bridge the quality divide. In fact, if we are not careful and if we do not find common ground, and hold government and the private sector to account, our entire healthcare system could well be in danger of failing – completely. 

The unreasonable man test – laying the groundwork for new ways of healthcare delivery

Although expediently signed into law with little regard to comments or concerns raised from many sectors including health and business, the NHI does lay the groundwork for new ways of delivering healthcare and sets the scene for changing the mindset from the current sick-care system mentality to one of a patient-empowered HEALTHcare system. 

Change must happen, but the extent of that change often depends on what Irish playwright and political activist, George Bernard Shaw, once stated as: “The reasonable man adapts himself to the world: the unreasonable one persists in trying to adapt the world to himself. Therefore all progress depends on the unreasonable man.”

At present, Prof Nicholas Crisp who has been tasked with helming the delivery of the NHI, could be seen as Shaw’s “unreasonable man” in his efforts to equalise and deliver universal healthcare.  Ensuring that the lever of technology is utilised in an effective way is critical though, to ensure that we don’t try and replicate previous perceived successes, and not move forwards.

With a challenged healthcare system, both public and private, we are called to not give up hope, but to lean into the solution, and at the same time, avoid a defensive posture of that which only served the few.  I believe that these circumstances force us to innovate, and to seriously consider new ways of providing healthcare for all. It should be seen as an exciting time of just where we can push the future of healthcare.

For instance, we already know that a traditional healthcare delivery system, with its associated costs and accessibility challenges for those living in remote parts of our country just won’t cut it.   But unlocking technology as the new delivery channel of healthcare complimented by affordable and fast internet, could well be the solution to cracking the code of healthcare for all.

Through technology we can drive the patient-centric approach to health and open the door for patients to more easily access the multi-disciplinary team of healthcare professionals they need.

The best of both worlds – prevention, and when required, recovery

An example of doing things differently, is a new approach to musculoskeletal health that has been facilitated by digital transformation, and which is finding growing adoption in South Africa.  With objective improvements in patient outcomes, satisfaction scores and recovery times, virtual care teams can support patients through their recovery programmes, ensuring improved compliance and ownership of their health journey.  And empowering patients to embrace exercise and activity over surgery and pharmaceuticals where appropriate, has a dramatic impact on the overall healthcare spend. 

Imagine patients having the choice to access a multi-disciplinary team of experts anywhere in the country – from the comfort and convenience of their own home or workplace, all at the tips of their fingers.  No need to be transported to a clinic or hospital every time they need healthcare services.  This is entirely possible, with platforms like Genie Health, that provide a hybrid approach in complimenting in-person care with virtual care.

NHI needs a strong front loader like these hybrid platforms that provide the full range of allied healthcare services, to reduce the burden of care and cost on an already strained system, by reducing unnecessary hospital admissions, surgeries, medication and travel costs and allowing for the existing framework to be brought up to date and even surpass expectations.  

With ICASA reporting over 75% of the population having Internet access in South Africa and more than 90% smartphone penetration, pressure on Mobile Network Operators to provide zero rated data for healthcare applications (as they have done in education and other areas) mounts. 

If measures like this can be implemented, they will have a tremendous impact on reducing the burden on the existing healthcare system through a self-health-empowered approach, with the backing of a full clinical team on the ready to assist the patient.

The ultimate question is how do we make healthcare more affordable and accessible to all South Africans, which is the core aim of the NHI?  

The answer – we need to renew our focus on the key stakeholder, our patients – and empower them to drive their own health, by using technology as the backbone for sustainable wellness. It could well be, that with a renewed mindset and health-empowered citizens, the NHI is the true gamechanger for progress in HEALTHcare that we all need.

Debunking Myths: The Truth About Medical Schemes in South Africa 

Despite the promise of Universal Health Coverage (UHC) for all, the recent signing of the NHI Bill has brought with it several misconceptions around medical schemes that undermine the very foundation of our healthcare system, writes Dr Katlego Mothudi, Managing Director at the Board of Healthcare Funders (BHF).

In a historic move aimed at transforming the South African healthcare landscape, President Cyril Ramaphosa signed the National Health Insurance (NHI) Bill into law. This landmark decision promises to move South Africa towards Universal Health Coverage (UHC) for all citizens, regardless of socio-economic status.

While the goal of UHC is commendable, the rhetoric leading up to the NHI Act’s announcement has created misconceptions about the role of medical schemes. 

With many believing that they should cancel their memberships immediately to enjoy free health services for the foreseeable future. However, Dr Katlego Mothudi clarifies that the implementation of NHI will take several years, dispelling this misconception.

The NHI Act introduces a single-payer system, central to the idea is that healthcare is a ‘public good’, suggesting all healthcare funding should exclude medical schemes, and should be government-funded. Dr Mothudi counters that healthcare is more accurately described as a social good. A public good, like military services, is one that the government must provide and from which no one can be excluded, regardless of payment. While healthcare is essential, it is not feasible to provide it as a public good.

The Board of Healthcare Funders (BHF), concerned about the numerous misconceptions propagated by government representatives since 2009, commissioned Professor Alex van den Heever, Chair of Social Security Systems Administration and Management Studies at Wits Health Consortium, to investigate these claims. Despite their hyperbolic nature and lack of systematic research, these statements have significant weight due to their endorsement by influential individuals. Prof van den Heever’s report identified frequently repeated assertions that he concluded were unsubstantiated and untrue.

Key Findings from the Report:

1. Medical Schemes are Unsustainable – False

In 2009, claims suggested that many medical schemes were headed for collapse due to unsustainable financing models, with 18 schemes reportedly nearing insolvency. Prof van den Heever’s report refutes this, showing stability in medical schemes from 2005 to 2022. The number of beneficiaries increased by over one million from 2009 to 2022, with consolidated reserves of R114 billion in 2022, far exceeding the required 25% reserve ratio. Broker costs have not been a systemic concern, and total non-health costs per average beneficiary per month for all medical schemes decreased by 34.7% in real terms from 2005 to 2020.

2. Health Services are a Public Good – False

   In 2011, Health Minister Aaron Motsoaledi claimed that private healthcare was a “brutal system” due to commercialisation. However, Prof. van den Heever clarified that healthcare is not a public good in the economic sense, as it does not meet the criteria of being jointly consumed without exclusion. Healthcare is a crucial service but providing it as a public good is not feasible.

3. Most Medical Scheme Beneficiaries are White – False

Last year, Prof Olive Shisana, an honorary professor at the University of Cape Town and special advisor to President Ramaphosa, stated that the private sector predominantly serves the privileged white population. However, Statistics South Africa’s 2021 research indicates that of the total population utilising private healthcare services, 50.2% are Black African, 32.3% are White, 9.8% are Coloured, and 7.6% are Indian/Asian.

Need for Balanced Perspectives

While the BHF supports healthcare reform, it raises concerns about the NHI Act’s constitutionality and calls for a factual review of claims about medical schemes. It is crucial to present both sides of the debate to understand the implications fully. Including government perspectives and addressing how the NHI will affect individual citizens would provide a more comprehensive view.

Medical schemes remain a valuable national asset that plays a crucial role in ensuring the long-term viability of South Africa’s healthcare ecosystem. BHF advocates for a balanced approach to healthcare reform that considers both public and private sectors’ strengths and weaknesses.

For a comprehensive look at findings from the report commissioned by BHF, see Prof van den Heever’s presentation at the 2024  Annual BHF Conference here. (Click to download PDF)

Let’s be Pragmatic – the NHI has Constructive and Contentious Aspects

By Susan Cleary for Spotlight

Professor Susan Cleary delivering her inaugural lecture as part of a lecture series by the University of Cape Town. (Photo: Supplied)

President Cyril Ramaphosa recently signed the NHI Bill into law. The question is whether this will bring South Africa closer towards Universal Health Coverage. Professor Susan Cleary argues that the NHI is a wide ranging reform with both positive and controversial aspects. The key will be to find a middle ground in order to continue on the journey to UHC.

President Cyril Ramaphosa signing the National Health Insurance (NHI) Act on the eve of the elections is a smart move from the perspective of a political party seeking to shore up its base. The concern though to those of us working to strengthen the health system is whether the NHI will enable the country to move closer towards Universal Health Coverage.

For the NHI naysayers, perhaps it would be important to alleviate some fears and concerns. The NHI is a long-term project. In the 2024 budget, National Treasury reduced the conditional grant allocations to the NHI in comparison to what was allocated in the 2023 budget. While signing the NHI Bill into law is a step forward, the reduction in resources towards NHI implementation reminds us that this is a long term project. In addition, it is likely that there will be legal challenges which will lead to considerable delays for the scheme to be fully implemented.

The NHI is a wide-ranging reform, with many positive aspects sitting alongside some key controversial aspects. Positive aspects include the opportunity to enable greater use of evidence and transparency in priority setting through the further institutionalisation of Health Technology Assessment processes (akin to ‘NICE’ in the UK), as well as the opportunity to use national-level purchasing power to drive down the prices of commodities such as medicines. The role of private multidisciplinary practices (GPs, nurses, health and rehabilitation professionals, etc) in the future NHI also holds some promise to improve access to healthcare particularly to parts of the country with limited access to public clinics.

On the other hand, there are two key controversial aspects. The first is related to what may or may not happen to medical schemes and medical scheme administrators once the NHI is fully implemented. My sense is that there is no short-term concern in this regard. A bigger concern is whether a single pot of money in the NHI fund will present a larger or a smaller corruption risk than the current situation of multiple pots spread across provincial treasuries and medical aid schemes.

Another concern is that the NHI reform might disrupt our ongoing progress towards Universal Health Coverage within our existing public sector. Our public sector is not perfect, but it is a system that has equity at its heart. The common definition of Universal Health Coverage is to provide all individuals and communities with access to needed promotive, preventive, resuscitative, curative, rehabilitative and palliative health services of sufficient quality to be effective, while ensuring that the utilisation of these services does not expose users to financial hardship.

The two main goals of Universal Health Coverage are: (1) the provision of quality health care services to those in need and (2) the avoidance of financial catastrophe in this process. Clearly healthcare is far from free – indeed it is very expensive – and so the goal of avoiding financial catastrophe is about implementing prepayment and risk pooling mechanisms, whether these are tax or insurance based.

Let’s first look at how we are doing on the provision of quality services. The below figure plots countries according to their achievements on the Universal Health Coverage Service Coverage Index. In this context, coverage of essential health services is measured based on indicators that include reproductive, maternal, newborn and child health, infectious diseases, non-communicable diseases and service capacity and access, among the general and the most disadvantaged populations.

On this index, South Africa’s achievement is at just over 70%, similar to many other middle-income countries. While there would be room for improvement, our performance is in line with our global peers.

Global comparison of countries in terms of service coverage and quality

Source: World Health Organization – Global Health Observatory (2024) processed by Our World in Data. Accessed May 2024.

The second indicator is financial risk protection. The below figure plots countries against the percent of total health expenditure that is paid out of pocket at the point of use. On this indicator, we score 5.7%, indicating extremely high levels of financial risk protection.

Global comparison of countries in terms of the percent of total health expenditure that is paid out of pocket

Source: World Health Organization (via World Bank) processed by Our World in Data. Accessed May 2024.

While this does not mean that there are no instances of financial catastrophe, undoubtedly there would be, particularly for those seeking treatment for certain types of cancers. That said, over the past two decades I have studied this issue extensively. Across a wide range of conditions in diverse settings, we have interviewed tens of thousands of people to understand the costs that they face in using health services, including everything from transport costs, to costs of food, shelter or accommodation, costs of child care, lost income, under the counter payments to public sector providers (which we never found), fees paid to private providers or money spent at pharmacies. This research consistently showed that the level of catastrophic spending was very low. Our performance on financial risk protection is outstanding. I celebrate the work of those colleagues that shepherded in the removal of user fees in our national health system during the dawning of our democracy. We should all be thanking them.

Despite these successes on Universal Health Coverage, there are areas of concern for the South African health system. We do not achieve health outcomes commensurate with our level of investment. My sense is that this is driven by our relatively high burden of disease; for example we continue to have the world’s largest HIV treatment programme. While our average life expectancy steadily increased with the introduction of antiretroviral therapy (although note the downturn from 2020 which coincides with the Covid-19 pandemic – see the below figure), the HIV epidemic has been a cruel setback that needs to be considered when we seek to make global comparisons on life expectancy and avertable mortality.

Global comparisons of life expectancy: 1970 – 2020

Source: United Nations World Population Prospects (2022) processed by Our World in Data. Accessed May 2024.

Now that the NHI Bill has become the NHI Act, it is time to move on from debates about whether we need NHI or not, and rather focus on how we can make the NHI work for us.

Our public sector will be the backbone of our future NHI and so we should seek to continue to strengthen this system. It would also be wise to put in place measures to strengthen our private system given that private providers are intended to play a key role in the NHI. We should be pragmatic.

The NHI includes many exciting opportunities for leveraging big data and artificial intelligence in health systems strengthening, but at this stage we hardly have any electronic health data. A clear step forward would be the further implementation of the National Digital Health Strategy (2019-2024) which includes the establishment of a patient electronic health record, amongst other needed developments.

In addition, the NHI places emphasis on the achievement of a purchaser provider split via establishing ‘Contracting Units for Primary Health Care’ (CUPS). These new entities will contract with both public and private providers within a defined geographic area, on behalf of a particular population. The establishment of CUP ‘proof of concept’ sites is therefore a priority, but must be done in a way that generates learning and enables adaptation to different contexts.

Let’s continue to push forward on many of these complex undertakings. It is going to take time, but it is needed, irrespective of the name that we choose to give to our health system.

*Cleary is professor of health economics and the head of the School of Public Health at the University of Cape Town.

Note: The views expressed in this opinion piece are not necessarily shared by the Spotlight editors. Spotlight is committed to publishing a variety of views and facilitating informed discussion that deepens public understanding of health issues.

Republished from Spotlight under a Creative Commons licence.

Source: Spotlight

Our Nurses, Our future: Addressing the Critical Issue of Sustainability in SA’s Healthcare Sector

Photo by Hush Naidoo on Unsplash

With only 22 090 nurses to serve the country’s public health sector of more than 50 million citizens1, urgent intervention is required to bolster their numbers and protect the wellbeing of our nation. After all, without their tireless dedication, who will be there to guide you through the corridors back to health? writes Bada Pharasi, CEO of the Innovative Pharmaceutical Association of South Africa (IPASA)

As the global healthcare industry commemorates International Nurses Day on 12 May, it is an opportune moment to reflect on the role of nurses as the heartbeat of healthcare systems globally. Amid turmoil and triumph, nurses stand as the unsung heroes and compassionate caretakers who embody empathy, endurance and expertise. 

In South Africa, where healthcare challenges often loom large and resources are stretched thin, nurses serve as the frontline warriors, bridging the gap between suffering and healing. Yet, despite the invaluable role they play, a concerning trend looms.

Minister of Health, Joe Phaahla, recently revealed a pressing concern – the anticipation of a staggering 30% of South African nurses retiring within the next decade, and 38% retiring the decade thereafter. Compounding the issue, 5060 vacancies remain unfilled on the back of crippling budget constraints1. 

Representing over 90% of global healthcare workers2, nurses are indispensable in the healthcare ecosystem, and addressing this impending crisis of their reducing numbers demands comprehensive and multifaceted solutions that approach the challenge from every angle.

The nurse shortage crisis in South Africa stems from multiple factors. Firstly, the escalating healthcare needs of a growing population, compounded by the burden of infectious diseases such as HIV/AIDS, have strained the healthcare system to breaking point.

Another factor is the restricted capacity of the private sector to train nurses comprehensively due to existing regulations. Moreover, poor working conditions, particularly in the public sector, and comparatively low salaries have led to high turnover rates, prompting nurses to explore alternative career paths or seek employment opportunities abroad3. 

While there are many challenges to defusing the proverbial ticking time bomb which is the declining number of qualified nurses in South Africa, increased investment across the board is critical to strengthening their ranks. 

Despite financial investment being central in realising this, addressing the problem demands a focus on improving the working conditions of nurses. Healthcare facilities must prioritise nurses’ well-being by offering competitive salaries, manageable workloads, and opportunities for career growth. By creating a supportive work environment, South Africa can retain more nurses and deter them from seeking opportunities abroad3.

Furthermore, granting private hospitals full participation in nurse training programmes is crucial. Private sector entities, such as Netcare, have the capacity to train as many as 3,500 nurses annually. However, limited accreditation from the government hampers their potential contribution to resolving the nurse shortage. Expanding private sector involvement in nurse training could substantially increase the number of trained nurses in the country3.

In addition to these measures, collaborative efforts between the government, healthcare institutions, and nursing organisations are essential. Such partnerships can identify and implement strategies to alleviate the shortage, including targeted recruitment drives, mentorship programmes, and initiatives to improve nurses’ job satisfaction and work-life balance3.

Innovative approaches to addressing the nurse shortage in South Africa extend beyond traditional solutions. Telemedicine platforms are emerging as a promising tool, allowing nurses to deliver care remotely and reach patients in underserved areas. 

Additionally, community health worker programmes are being expanded to complement nursing services and extend healthcare access to marginalised communities. Furthermore, initiatives to empower and support nurse entrepreneurs are gaining traction, encouraging the development of innovative care models and healthcare solutions. 

These diverse approaches reflect a multifaceted response to the nurse shortage crisis, leveraging technology, community engagement, and entrepreneurship to strengthen the healthcare workforce and improve access to care for all South Africans.

References:

1. Only 22 000 nurses for 50 million South Africans [Internet]. Democratic Alliance. [cited 2024 May 2]. Available from: https://www.da.org.za/2023/06/only-22-000-nurses-for-50-million-south-africans

2. Experiences of nurses and midwives in policy development in low- and middle-income countries: Qualitative systematic review. International Journal of Nursing Studies Advances. 2023 Dec 1;5:100116.

3. [Opinion] Nurse shortage crisis in South Africa [Internet]. Centre for Risk Analysis. 2023 [cited 2024 May 2]. Available from: https://cra-sa.com/media/opinion-nurse-shortage-crisis-in-south-africa

Opinion Piece: Addressing Sanitation Challenges – A Call for Prioritising Basic Needs in South Africa’s Upcoming Elections

By Robert Erasmus, Managing Director at Sanitech

Photo by Hush Naidoo Jade Photography on Unsplash

In South Africa, and across many developing nations, the discourse leading up to elections often centre on fundamental issues that directly impact the daily lives of citizens, such as the cost of living and access to clean water and sanitation. As the world witnesses a significant portion of its population gearing up to vote in 2024, it becomes evident that the voting criteria in developing countries vastly differ from those in developed ones.

While developed nations may debate topics like climate change and immigration, citizens in developing countries like South Africa are primarily concerned with securing basic necessities for survival and dignity. The disparity in voting patterns reflects the stark contrast in the challenges faced by people living in different parts of the world.

Elevating the discussion on South Africa’s paradox

South Africa, despite being regarded relatively highly in terms of election fairness, grapples with persistent challenges in providing access to clean water and adequate sanitation facilities. Our democratic process works, but it needs to be leveraged correctly for the benefit of our people. Many communities across the country continue to suffer due to the absence of proper sanitation infrastructure, perpetuating cycles of poverty and disease. The lack of clean water exacerbates these challenges, posing significant obstacles to health, dignity, and economic progress.

The interconnectedness of health, dignity, and economic progress

It is worth noting that the voting populace in South Africa has shifted its focus from ideological differences to practical concerns about the delivery of basic human rights. This shift underscores the importance of addressing the immediate needs of citizens before delving into broader policy discussions. Without access to clean water and sanitation, individuals and communities struggle to break free from the cycle of poverty and disease, hindering their ability to participate fully in economic and social life.

The impact of inadequate sanitation and clean water access extends beyond health and dignity – it also affects economic progress. Families burdened with preventable illnesses spend precious resources on healthcare instead of investing in education and livelihoods. Children often sacrifice their education to care for sick family members, further perpetuating the cycle of poverty. To address these challenges, practical solutions must be prioritised that ensure equitable access to clean water and sanitation for all citizens to break the cycle of poverty and disease and pave the way for economic growth.

Solving South Africa’s challenges starts with sanitation

These solutions include investing in infrastructure that can provide clean water and adequate sanitation facilities to all communities, especially those in rural and underserved areas, while at the same time investing in the repair and maintenance of existing infrastructure.

Implementing technologies such as water purification systems and innovative sanitation solutions tailored to local needs can help bridge the gap in access. Additionally, community engagement and education programs are essential to promote hygiene practices and ensure the long-term sustainability of water and sanitation initiatives. By prioritising these solutions, South Africa can make significant strides towards ensuring equitable access to clean water and sanitation for all its citizens.

Advocating for real change beyond election promises

Citizens have a central role to play in advocating for real commitment from political candidates. By elevating the discussion around sanitation and clean water access, voters are better informed to hold leaders accountable for delivering on their promises. Political parties must recognise the importance of addressing basic needs and commit to implementing sustainable solutions that uplift communities and promote dignity. For political parties this will be one of the most effective ways to win and retain the vote.

As we get closer to election date, it is essential to correctly prioritise the basic needs of citizens, including access to clean water and sanitation. This is not a critique of the government but a call to action – a recognition of the fundamental rights that must be upheld for all individuals to thrive. By addressing sanitation challenges, South Africa can pave the way for a future where every citizen has the opportunity to live a healthy, dignified life and contribute to the nation’s prosperity.